Friday, November 20, 2020

Janczarski & Siddik 4tet - Contemplation (2020)

Janczarski & Siddik 4tet

Borys Janczarski - tenor saxophone
Rasul Siddik - trumpet, flute
Michał Jaros - double bass
Kazimierz Jonkisz - drums

Contemplation

FOR TUNE 0147

By Adam Baruch

This is a live recording at the Warsaw 12 on 14 Jazz Club by the quartet co-led by Polish Jazz saxophonist Borys Janczarski and veteran American trumpeter Rasul Siddik, with Polish bassist Michał Jaros and veteran drummer Kazimierz Jonkisz. Together they perform seven pieces, six of which are Jazz standards and one is an original composition by Siddik.

The album offers a warm and authentic club atmosphere but the music is all strictly within American mainstream boundaries and is completely predictable. This is a third recorded collaboration between Janczarski and Siddik released on the For Tune label, all of which follow the same well established pattern of Bebop oriented music making, which has hardly changed in the last 70 years or so.

As for the performances, despite the fact that Siddik has a well earned reputation of playing with some very important American Jazz names in the past, his playing here (and on the two other a.m. albums) is very shaky and unimpressive, Janczarski is much more vigorous but not really notable and only the excellent rhythm section is up for the job, especially Jaros whose bass parts are the absolute highlights of this album.

Overall this music might have been nice to listen to at the club while enjoying a drink, but has no lasting value beyond that. At least the music is well recorded by Tomasz Pierchała, the club owner and persistent Warsaw Jazz scene activist.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...