Sunday, February 19, 2012

Tomasz Stanko - Tales For A Girl (Polonia Records, 1995) by Thom Jurek


Tomasz Stańko -  trumpet 

Janusz Skowron -  synthesizer   

Tales For A Girl, 12 (Polonia Records, 1995)






This is Polish trumpeter and composer Tomasz Stanko at his most confounding. Paired with Janisz Skowron on synthesizer, Stanko claims that these pieces are nothing more than short little musical stories -- not fully realized compositions, but sketches. That's reasonable enough, but when certain pieces -- such as the opener -- are nine minutes in length, that becomes somewhat tenuous as an explanation. The 12 pieces that make up this "suite," if indeed it can be called that, are ephemeral roots and seedlings of ideas not yet realized and not meant to be. This, too, is acceptable as a notion, but why record them? Perhaps Brian Eno can get away with nonsense like this since he's not -- by his own admission -- a musician, but Stanko is an ambitious talent, a sophisticated composer whose control over an ensemble brings out the sublime in them. This is throwaway music, ignoble and forgettable and not worth the time or materials it took to produce. A bitter disappointment.



Author: Thom Jurek

1 comment:

  1. Jurek is supposed to be a serious Jazz writer and he's been out there since many years, so I have no idea where did all this nonsense he wrote here come from? Oh, wait a minute.... he's an American! - That must be it... As usual American Jazz critics can't see an inch beyond their short (culturally) nose and anything that has not originated on America can't be Jazz

    Mr. Jurek, please spare us your wisdom and go and listen to a some of the numerous Stanko albums, read the liner notes, read a book or two about Stanko, Polish Jazz, East-European Jazz, European Jazz…. anything…before you voice an opinion.

    Of course in America anybody is free to say anything….

    ReplyDelete

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...